ThesisEmbargo

Divorce initiated by woman in Islamic jurisprudence and its implications for women's rights

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Universitas Islam Internasional Indonesia

Publisher DOI

Volume

Issue

Resources

Total Views: 0Total Downloads: 0
download count data not available for this item.

Abstract

In Islamic law, the power to dissolve a marriage is not equally shared. A husband can divorce his wife unilaterally through talaq, while a wife must rely on more limited legal mechanisms, such as khul', faskh, tafriq, or ta'liq talaq. However, women also face procedural barriers. They usually need a judge's decision or the husband's consent. And substantive barriers because they may have to prove legal grounds, such as darar (harm) or shiqaq (marital discord), or pay iwad (compensation). Since the late nineteenth century, many muslim countries have reformed these rules, but each has taken a different path. This study asks how far women's access to divorce has been reformed in both doctrinal and practice. This study develops a five-dimension analytical framework consisting of legal classification, the husband's consent, the role of compensation ('iwad), judicial authority, and the grounds required for divorce. This framework is applied to the classical schools of law, five modern Muslim jurisdictions, and Indonesia judicial practice evaluated against CEDAW and constitutional standards using a normative doctrinal and comparative method. This study reaches three main findings. First, among classical school, the Maliki tradition provides women with the broadest access to divorce because a judge may dissolve the marriage without the husband's consent and compensation is not required. Second, modern legal reform has expanded women's access to divorce, but the reforms remain partial and uneven because many jurisdictions retain the financial axis of khul'. Third although Indonesia formally follows the Shafi'i tradition, its judicial practice has functionally converged with the Maliki tradition. Women can obtain a divorce without the husband's consent and compensation no longer operates as a practical barrier. However, women's post-divorce financial rights remain inadequately protected, resulting in indirect discrimination under CEDAW. This study contributes a transferable analytical framework and argues that broader access to divorce for women can be justified within the Islamic legal tradition itself.

Description

Citation

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By

License

Except where otherwised noted, this item's license is described as All Rights Reserved